I believe that the smokescreen of tax paid v benefits, is just that. It does not take in to account the impact on our economy as a whole e.g. schools, housing, Health.
It is an obvious fact that all these three areas have been under resourced for years. The amount of tax being paid by UK nationals, could not cover the demands of that UK population. Therefore any net gain of tax over benefits paid by EU immigrants, will never cover the cost of schooling them, taking care of their health, providing housing etc.
It is not being racist to point out the obvious that children who attend schools, who are not english speaking, have a greater economic impact on schooling than your average english speaking pupil.
It is not being racist to point out that a non english speaking person arriving in hospital will have a greater cost than an english speaking patient. You only have to note the numerous signs advising the patients to let staff know if they need a translator. If they want a form in a different language etc. This all costs extra money. Have been to hospitals a few times in France and have never once been offered access to a translator or forms in English. Maybe I just looked intellectual lol
Tax v Benefits, is only part of the problem. High youth unemployment in EU is a problem , in reality, Spain's high rate of unemployment, is also our high rate of unemployment.
Whatever the government promises us, Greek debt is also our debt. France and germany's immigration problems is also our immigration problem - do you think we would be pumping so much money into refugee camps, if it wasn't for the sight of hundreds of thousands making their way to France and Germany ?
Turkey's immigration issues have now become our immigration issues. More of our money flowing out to pacify the EU open borders. To even consider Turkey having visa free access, never mind joining the EU is laughable. But the people making these decisions are the people we are in bed with.
I find myself knowing if I was being invited to join this mess, rather than being asked to decide to leave it. My decision would be much much much easier